Skip to main content

Get 15% off your first order

Shipping Policy

Fast, tracked, and carefully packaged shipping on every order.

Processing Time

Orders are packed and shipped within 1-2 business days of payment (Monday to Friday, excluding US holidays). Orders placed after 2 PM Eastern, on weekends or on holidays begin processing the next business day.

Before an order ships, every game is boot-tested and its save is checked, so we never send a cartridge we haven't verified.

Shipping Methods We Offer

All orders ship with USPS. Live rates for your address are shown at checkout, so you only pay what the label actually costs.

ServiceEstimated delivery*Best for
USPS Ground Advantage2-5 business daysMost game orders, the most affordable choice
USPS Priority Mail1-3 business daysFaster delivery, gifts, consoles
USPS Priority Mail Express1-2 business daysWhen you need it right away
USPS First-Class International / Priority International6-20 business daysOrders outside the US

*Delivery times are USPS estimates that start once your package is scanned. They are not guaranteed and can be longer during holidays or bad weather.

Free Shipping

  • Free standard shipping on US orders of $50 or more (after discounts, before tax).
  • Paid NicestFinds members (Insider, Collector and Curator) get free US shipping on every order, with no minimum.
  • Curator members get free USPS Priority Mail on every US order.
  • Free shipping applies to US addresses only (all 50 states, plus APO/FPO/DPO and US territories).

How We Pack Your Order

  • Cartridges are sealed in an anti-static sleeve, then shipped in a padded bubble mailer or box.
  • Larger orders, boxed games and collectibles ship in a rigid box with padding on all sides so nothing shifts.
  • Consoles and handhelds ship in reinforced boxes with foam or air padding, and their screens and ports are protected.
  • Trading cards ship in a penny sleeve and top loader, and higher-value cards also get a bubble mailer or box.
  • Multiple items in one order are combined into one package whenever possible to save you shipping.

Tracking Your Order

Once your order ships you'll get an email with your USPS tracking number. You can also see your order status and tracking under My Account. Tracking can take up to 24 hours to show the first scan.

Auction and Trading Card Shipping

Trading card auction lots use tiered shipping based on the winning price:

  • Under $20: standard envelope ($1) or USPS Ground Advantage ($5).
  • $20-$49.99: Ground Advantage ($5), Priority Mail ($10) or Priority Mail Express ($35).
  • $50 and up: free Ground Advantage, or upgrade to Priority ($10) or Express ($35).
  • Other auction lots show their shipping price on the listing. Winning several lots? Combine them into one shipment at checkout.

International Shipping

We ship worldwide with USPS. International rates are calculated at checkout from your address and package weight, and these orders don't qualify for free shipping.

Customs duties, import taxes and brokerage fees are set by your country and paid by the buyer when the package arrives. We aren't able to mark packages as gifts or lower the declared value.

Address Changes and Delivery Problems

  • Please check your shipping address at checkout. Need to change it? Contact us right away. We can update it as long as the order hasn't shipped.
  • Packages returned to us because of an incorrect or incomplete address can be reshipped once you cover the new postage.
  • If tracking shows delivered but you can't find the package, check with neighbors and your local post office, then contact us within 7 days and we'll help file a claim.
  • If no tracking updates appear for 10 or more business days (US), contact us and we'll open a USPS trace and work with you on a replacement or refund.

Damaged Packages

If your order arrives damaged, take photos of the item and packaging and contact us within 7 days of delivery. We'll send a replacement or a full refund under our 30-day quality guarantee, with no return shipping cost to you.

Questions about an order? Contact us or see our Returns Policy.

Ready to Shop?

Browse our full catalog of premium, tested retro games.

Browse Catalog