NicestFinds Rewards
Every order you place builds your collection and your balance. Earn 5 points per $1 — 5% back to start, up to 10% back at the top tier — plus early access, extended returns and collector perks.
How It Works
Shop the catalog
Every paid order earns points automatically on the email you check out with — no codes, no forms.
Earn 5 points per $1
That's 5% back at the base tier, and up to 10% back once you reach Platinum. Points never expire.
Redeem for money off
100 points = $1 off. Cash out for a coupon code that works at checkout for 90 days.
Membership Tiers
Earn your way up automatically by shopping — every paid order adds to your trailing 12-month spend.
8-BIT STARTER PAK
SER# NF-85-BRZ
Collector Tier
Bronze
Included Base Perks:
- 5% back in points
- Birthday bonus points
- Members-only restock alerts
- Points never expire
16-BIT SUPER PAK
SER# NF-91-SLV
Collector Tier
Silver
Includes Bronze + Unlocks:
- 6.25% back in points
- 24-hour early access to new arrivals
- Free wishlist sourcing requests
- Extended 45-day returns
64-BIT ULTRA PAK
SER# NF-96-GLD
Collector Tier
Gold
Includes Silver + Unlocks:
- 7.5% back in points
- 48-hour early access to new arrivals
- Priority order handling & support
- Extended 60-day returns
- Free condition photos on request
HOLO MASTER PAK
SER# NF-99-PLT
Collector Tier
Platinum
Includes Gold + Unlocks:
- 10% back in points
- First dibs on rare inventory before listing
- Extended 90-day returns
- Personal collector concierge
- Double points in your birthday month
What Your Points Are Worth
Bank points for bigger rewards — the higher rungs give you more value per point.
$5 off
500 points
≈ $100 of spending
$10 off
1,000 points
≈ $200 of spending
$25 off
2,000 points
≈ $400 of spending
$50 off
3,500 points
≈ $700 of spending
Paid Memberships
Insider
$20 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Silver status — 1.25x points on every order
- $10 store credit every month — pays for half your membership
- 1 reproduction game credit every month — up to $50
- Free standard shipping on every order
- 48-hour early access to new arrivals
- Priority order handling & support
- Extended 60-day returns
Collector
$50 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Gold status — 1.5x points on every order
- $30 store credit every month
- 1 reproduction game credit every month — up to $50
- Free standard shipping on every order
- First dibs on rare inventory before it's listed
- Extended 90-day returns
- Personal collector concierge
Curator
$100 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Platinum status — 2x points, our highest earn rate
- $50 store credit every month
- 2 reproduction game credits every month — up to $50 each
- Free Priority shipping & free returns, always
- Unlimited wishlist sourcing — we hunt your grails
- Reserved 48-hour holds on any new arrival
- Double points on your birthday month
Memberships are recurring subscriptions purchased through our store checkout. Your card is charged automatically each month until you cancel — cancel anytime and your perks keep running through the end of the paid period. They activate on the email used at checkout.
Monthly game codes cover up to $50 per reproduction game. Codes are single-use; any remaining balance is forfeited. View Terms & Conditions
Rewards FAQ
Ready to cash in?
Sign in to see your balance, tier progress, order history and redeem your points.
Go to My Account