NicestFinds Rewards
Every order you place builds your collection and your balance. Earn 5 points per $1 — 5% back to start, up to 10% back at the top tier — plus early access, extended returns and collector perks.
How It Works
Shop the catalog
Every paid order earns points automatically on the email you check out with — no codes, no forms.
Earn 5 points per $1
That's 5% back at the base tier, and up to 10% back once you reach Platinum. Points never expire.
Redeem for money off
100 points = $1 off. Cash out for a coupon code that works at checkout for 90 days.
Membership Tiers
Earn your way up by shopping — every paid order adds to your trailing-12-month spend.
Bronze
Everyone
- 5% back in points
- Birthday bonus points
- Members-only restock alerts
- Points never expire
Silver
$250+ / year
Everything in Bronze, plus:
- 6.25% back in points
- 24-hour early access to new arrivals
- Free wishlist sourcing requests
- Extended 45-day returns
Gold
$750+ / year
Everything in Silver, plus:
- 7.5% back in points
- 48-hour early access to new arrivals
- Priority order handling & support
- Extended 60-day returns
- Free condition photos on request
Platinum
$1500+ / year
Everything in Gold, plus:
- 10% back in points
- First dibs on rare inventory before listing
- Extended 90-day returns
- Personal collector concierge
- Double points on your birthday
What Your Points Are Worth
Bank points for bigger rewards — the higher rungs give you more value per point.
$5 off
500 points
≈ $100 of spending
$10 off
1,000 points
≈ $200 of spending
$25 off
2,000 points
≈ $400 of spending
$50 off
3,500 points
≈ $700 of spending
Paid Memberships
Insider
$20 / mo
- Instant Silver status — 1.25x points on every order
- $10 store credit every month — pays for half your membership
- 1 free game every month, on us
- Free standard shipping on every order
- 48-hour early access to new arrivals
- Priority order handling & support
- Extended 60-day returns
Collector
$50 / mo
- Instant Gold status — 1.5x points on every order
- $30 store credit every month
- 1 free game every month, on us
- Free standard shipping on every order
- First dibs on rare inventory before it's listed
- Extended 90-day returns
- Personal collector concierge
Curator
$100 / mo
- Instant Platinum status — 2x points, our highest earn rate
- $50 store credit every month
- 2 free games every month, on us
- Free Priority shipping & free returns, always
- Unlimited wishlist sourcing — we hunt your grails
- Reserved 48-hour holds on any new arrival
- Double points on your birthday month
Memberships are recurring subscriptions purchased through our store checkout. Your card is charged automatically each month until you cancel — cancel anytime and your perks keep running through the end of the paid period. They activate on the email used at checkout.
Rewards FAQ
Ready to cash in?
Sign in to see your balance, tier progress, order history and redeem your points.
Go to My Account