NicestFinds Memberships
Unlock a higher rewards tier instantly, plus monthly store credit, reproduction game credits and free shipping. Pay monthly or save with annual — cancel anytime.
Try Insider Free for 30 Days — Unlock $60+ in Perks Today
First-time members can start with a $0 checkout today, then $20/mo after 30 days. Cancel from your account after 7 days anytime before day 30.
- $10 monthly store credit + 1 free reproduction game credit (up to $50)
- Free standard U.S. shipping on every order
- Instant Silver status (1.25x points) & 60-day returns
Paid Memberships
Insider
$20 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Silver status — 1.25x points on every order
- $10 store credit every month — pays for half your membership
- 1 reproduction game credit every month — up to $50
- Free standard shipping on every order
- 48-hour early access to new arrivals
- Priority order handling & support
- Extended 60-day returns
Collector
$50 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Gold status — 1.5x points on every order
- $30 store credit every month
- 1 reproduction game credit every month — up to $50
- Free standard shipping on every order
- First dibs on rare inventory before it's listed
- Extended 90-day returns
- Personal collector concierge
Curator
$100 / mo
Save 17% with annual- Instant Platinum status — 2x points, our highest earn rate
- $50 store credit every month
- 2 reproduction game credits every month — up to $50 each
- Free Priority shipping & free returns, always
- Unlimited wishlist sourcing — we hunt your grails
- Reserved 48-hour holds on any new arrival
- Double points on your birthday month
Memberships are recurring subscriptions purchased through our store checkout. Your card is charged automatically each month until you cancel — cancel anytime and your perks keep running through the end of the paid period. They activate on the email used at checkout.
Monthly game codes cover up to $50 per reproduction game. Codes are single-use; any remaining balance is forfeited. View Terms & Conditions
The Membership Math
See how a single monthly order pays for your membership more than 3× over
$50/mo
1 reproduction game up to $50 ea
$10/mo
Spendable on anything in store
$6+/mo
Free Standard Shipping + 1.25x Silver Points
$66+/mo value
You pay $20/mo · Come out +$46/mo ahead
Live Showcase: Claim Any Reproduction Game Up to $50 Free Every Month
Every paid plan includes at least 1 monthly reproduction game credit (Curator gets 2/mo). Pick any in-stock cartridge ≤ $50:
GBC$0 w/ CreditDonkey Kong Country – Nintendo Game Boy Color (GBC) Platformer Game
GBA$0 w/ CreditNES vs SEGA GBA Cartridge – 256 Classic Games (150 NES/106 SEGA)
DS$0 w/ CreditMario & Luigi: Partners in Time – Nintendo DS (NDS) Role-Playing Game
DS$0 w/ CreditAce Attorney Games (Nintendo DS)
DS$0 w/ CreditCastlevania Nintendo DS Games (DS)
DS$0 w/ CreditPokemon Platinum, Pearl, & Diamond – Nintendo DS (NDS) RPG Collection Game
DS$0 w/ CreditDK Jungle Climber NDS Game (Nintendo DS)
DS$0 w/ CreditDragon Ball Z 1 & 2 for Nintendo DS!
Membership FAQ
Free rewards program details on the Rewards page · Read the Membership Terms