Membership Terms & Conditions

These Membership Terms & Conditions govern NicestFinds Insider, Collector and Curator paid memberships, including monthly and annual subscriptions. Review them before purchasing or renewing a membership and retain a copy for your records.

These terms supplement our Terms of Service, Shipping Policy, Returns Policy and Privacy Policy. For membership-specific matters, these terms control if there is a conflict with a general store policy. Nothing in these terms excludes or limits rights or remedies that cannot lawfully be excluded or limited.

Insider includes $10 in monthly store credit, one free reproduction game per membership month, Silver status with a 1.25x points multiplier, free standard shipping, 48-hour early access to new arrivals, priority handling and support, and a 60-day product return window.

Collector includes $30 in monthly store credit, one free reproduction game per membership month, Gold status with a 1.5x points multiplier, free standard shipping, early access to rare inventory, a 90-day product return window, and collector concierge assistance.

Curator includes $50 in monthly store credit, two free reproduction games per membership month, Platinum status with a 2x points multiplier, free Priority shipping and free returns, wishlist sourcing, reserved 48-hour holds on new arrivals, and the advertised birthday-month points benefit.

Annual billing does not mean all monthly benefits are delivered upfront. Free games and store credit are monthly entitlements during the active paid term, not a single annual allowance. Billing frequency and benefit frequency are separate.

Each monthly game entitlement is a single-use benefit code worth up to $50 toward one in-stock reproduction game sold individually by NicestFinds. Eligible games priced at $50 or less are covered in full; for an eligible game priced above $50, you pay the difference. The $50 maximum applies to each code, including each of Curator's two monthly codes.

Authentic or original-release games, graded or sealed collectible items, consoles, handhelds, accessories, trading cards, other collectibles, multi-item bundles, auction lots, gift cards and membership subscriptions do not qualify. A reproduction game is not an original-release collectible; review the product listing for its format, compatibility and condition.

Insider and Collector receive one eligible game per membership month; Curator receives two. Each entitlement applies to one unit, not an entire cart. Entitlements cannot be combined into a different item or exchanged for cash or store credit, and are not transferable.

Selection is subject to stock at the time of redemption. A specific title, platform or restock date is not guaranteed. If an eligible title becomes unavailable before fulfillment, contact us to select another available reproduction game.

Unused monthly game entitlements do not roll over. Claim them before the applicable monthly expiration shown in your account. The benefit covers up to $50 of the eligible game's item price; applicable tax and any shipping not covered by your plan remain subject to checkout and applicable law.

Use the same email for your membership checkout and NicestFinds account so purchases and benefits can be linked correctly. Sign in to review your membership, benefit codes and displayed expiration dates. Contact us promptly if a benefit is missing, an email is incorrect, or a code does not apply as expected.

Benefits follow membership months rather than calendar months. A monthly benefit period is tied to your membership start date; annual members continue to receive benefits month by month. Check the displayed expiration for each issued code rather than assuming benefits last until the end of a calendar month or year.

Apply the appropriate benefit when ordering and review the total before payment. Each game code provides a fixed discount of up to $50, not an unlimited discount or a percentage off the whole cart. Any unused portion is forfeited when the single-use code is redeemed; it does not become a new code or a stored balance. Contact us before paying if a code does not apply as expected.

Codes are single-use. Monthly store credit and free-game entitlements are separate benefits; do not assume they can be stacked with each other or with another promotion in the same checkout. Contact us if you need help redeeming separate benefits.

Membership prices are stated in US dollars. The selected plan, recurring charge, billing interval and applicable taxes are shown at checkout. Monthly plans renew monthly; annual plans renew every 12 months. Annual membership fees are charged upfront, not in monthly installments.

By completing a subscription purchase, you authorize recurring charges to your chosen payment method for the selected plan until cancellation. Renewal dates and payment details are provided through your subscription account and checkout records.

Annual pricing is currently equivalent to ten monthly payments rather than twelve. Advertised percentage savings may be rounded and compare the annual price with twelve payments at the corresponding monthly price; they are not a cash credit.

A failed or reversed payment may interrupt membership access and benefits. Keep your payment details current and contact us about a billing error. Payment recovery does not create duplicate benefit entitlements for the same membership period.

You may cancel automatic renewal at any time using the cancellation controls provided for your subscription or by contacting us through our Contact page with your membership email. Cancel before your next renewal is processed to stop that charge, and retain your cancellation confirmation. If you do not receive confirmation, contact us to check the status.

Cancellation stops future renewals; it does not end the period already paid for. Membership benefits continue through that paid period, subject to each monthly benefit's own expiration date, and end when the paid term expires.

Membership fees are non-refundable for a paid monthly or annual term, including unused benefits, partial periods and early cancellation, except where a refund is required by applicable law. Cancelling an annual membership does not convert it to monthly billing or entitle you to a prorated refund.

Signing out, no longer using the account, or removing the app is not a cancellation request. Contact us about cancellation before deleting your account. This non-refundable membership-fee policy is separate from product-return rights and does not restrict claims concerning unauthorized or erroneous charges.

Monthly store credit is provided as a benefit code in the amount applicable to your plan: $10 for Insider, $30 for Collector and $50 for Curator. It is separate from the free-game entitlement and is not cash or a purchased gift card.

Membership credit cannot be used toward membership fees, gift cards or auction payments. It is personal to the member and cannot be sold, transferred or exchanged for cash, except as required by law.

Review the expiration shown with each code. Monthly credit does not roll over unless expressly stated on the code. Cancelling renewal does not extend a code's original expiration or accelerate future monthly credits.

While active, a membership grants its advertised tier and points benefit. If your spending-earned tier is higher, you keep the better tier. When membership ends, the paid tier benefit ends and your tier is determined under the regular Rewards program rules.

Eligible points-earning spend is product subtotal after discounts, excluding tax, shipping and refunded amounts. Free items do not earn points on a price you did not pay. Returns and refunds may result in corresponding rewards adjustments.

Membership benefit codes are distinct from coupons redeemed with reward points, and their expiration rules may differ. Membership cancellation alone does not cause your existing points balance to expire.

Membership shipping benefits apply to domestic orders at the service level advertised for your plan: standard shipping for Insider and Collector, and Priority shipping for Curator. International shipping and upgrades not included in the plan may incur additional charges. Check the shipping total before paying and contact us if an included benefit is missing.

Our normal handling time is 1–2 business days. Priority handling and shipping benefits do not guarantee a carrier delivery date. See the Shipping Policy for delivery details.

Insider's 60-day and Collector's 90-day return windows apply to products ordered while the membership is active and run from delivery. Other return conditions remain governed by the Returns Policy. Cancellation does not shorten an applicable return window for an order already placed.

Free reproduction games remain covered by our product quality policy. Contact us about defects or incorrect items. A no-charge game does not carry a cash refund equal to its retail price; remedies required by law remain available. Product refunds otherwise reflect the amount actually paid after discounts, not the undiscounted list price.

Early access, concierge assistance and wishlist sourcing depend on available inventory. These benefits do not guarantee that a particular item will be found, stocked or sold at a particular price. Sourced items are purchased separately unless they independently qualify for the free reproduction-game benefit.

Contact us to arrange a Curator hold and confirm its start and end time. A hold is not a purchase or ownership transfer; payment is required to complete the order. Contact us with your interests or wishlist to use personal assistance benefits.

Membership is personal to the account holder and linked to the checkout email. Keep that email accessible and do not share, resell or transfer benefit codes. You must be legally able to enter the subscription agreement and authorized to use the payment method.

Before changing plans or billing frequency, contact us to confirm the effective date, price and treatment of existing benefits. Do not assume that buying a second subscription cancels the first, merges benefits, or creates a prorated credit.

We may investigate suspected fraud or benefit misuse and restrict affected benefits or accounts as permitted by law. You may contact us to dispute an error. Nothing in these terms removes your right to raise a legitimate billing dispute or seek a legally required remedy.

We will give at least 30 days' notice of a membership price change before it applies to a future billing period. A price change does not retroactively change the price of a term already paid for, and you may cancel renewal before the new price takes effect.

Updated terms will be posted here with a revision date. We will notify active members of material changes and obtain any consent required by law. Changes will not retroactively remove benefits already owed for a paid term. If the program is discontinued, we will communicate how outstanding paid-term obligations will be handled in accordance with applicable law.

Membership and order information is handled under our Privacy Policy. Subscription receipts, billing notices and membership-service communications are separate from optional marketing preferences.

Mandatory consumer protections, including any applicable cancellation, refund and warranty rights, take priority over conflicting wording here. If a provision is unenforceable, the remaining provisions continue to apply to the extent permitted by law.

For benefit redemption, cancellation, billing corrections or a complaint, use our Contact page and provide your membership email and relevant order number. Do not send passwords or full payment-card details.